top of page
Search

Why your Best technical expert might be your Worst people Manager

Writer: Viwe Gobodo
Viwe Gobodo
Oct 26
3 min read

In many organisations, promoting high-performing employees into management seems like the obvious next step. The engineer who consistently delivers exceptional projects becomes Engineering Manager. The top salesperson is appointed Sales Manager. The experienced artisan is promoted to Supervisor.


On paper, these decisions make perfect sense.


In practice, however, they often become the starting point of leadership challenges that cost organisations far more than they realise.


The assumption that technical excellence naturally translates into leadership capability remains one of the most expensive mistakes organisations make.



Technical competence and leadership are different skills


Technical expertise earns credibility. Leadership earns commitment.

An exceptional engineer understands systems, processes and problem-solving. A great leader understands people, motivation and influence.


Likewise, an outstanding financial professional may possess remarkable analytical ability but still struggle to conduct difficult conversations, resolve conflict or build trust within a team.

These are not personality flaws. They are leadership competencies that require deliberate development.


Unfortunately, many newly promoted managers receive authority without receiving the skills needed to lead effectively.



The hidden organisational costs


When managers lack people leadership capability, the consequences often extend well beyond team morale.

Organisations may begin to experience:


  • Increased disciplinary cases.

  • Higher employee turnover.

  • Poor engagement and declining productivity.

  • Escalating grievances.

  • Increased absenteeism.

  • Burnout among both managers and employees.

  • Growing conflict between departments.


In many cases, Human Resources becomes occupied managing symptoms while the underlying leadership capability gap remains unaddressed.

By the time these issues appear in reports and dashboards, the financial and operational costs have already accumulated.



Emotional intelligence is no longer optional


Modern workplaces demand more than operational expertise.

Managers are expected to lead multigenerational teams, navigate cultural diversity, manage hybrid work environments, respond to employee wellbeing concerns and maintain high performance under constant change.


This requires emotional intelligence as much as technical knowledge.


Leaders who demonstrate self-awareness, empathy, resilience and effective communication create environments where employees feel respected, accountable and motivated.

Conversely, managers who rely solely on technical authority often struggle to inspire discretionary effort or maintain trust during difficult periods.



Leadership failures often become labour relations issues


One of the most overlooked realities in organisations is that many employee relations problems begin as leadership problems.


Employees rarely submit grievances because a manager lacks technical knowledge.

They raise concerns because they feel unheard, unfairly treated, poorly communicated with or inconsistently managed.


Likewise, disciplinary problems are not always indicators of poor employee behaviour alone. They may also reflect inadequate supervision, unclear expectations, inconsistent accountability or ineffective coaching.

When organisations invest only in disciplinary processes without strengthening leadership capability, they risk treating the symptoms while ignoring the cause.



Promotion should not be the end of development


Too often, promotion is treated as the reward.

In reality, promotion should mark the beginning of a structured leadership development journey.

Organisations should equip newly appointed managers with practical skills in areas such as:


  • Emotional intelligence.

  • Giving constructive feedback.

  • Managing difficult conversations.

  • Conflict resolution.

  • Performance coaching.

  • Employment law fundamentals.

  • Inclusive leadership.

  • Decision-making under pressure.


Leadership is a profession in its own right. It deserves the same investment as any technical discipline.



A better question to ask


Instead of asking:

"Who is our best technical performer?"


Organisations should also ask:

"Who has demonstrated the ability to develop others, build trust, manage conflict and create high-performing teams?"


The answers to those questions are not always the same.

And recognising that difference may be one of the most valuable leadership decisions an organisation makes.



Technical expertise builds products, delivers services and solves operational problems.

Leadership builds the environment in which people choose to perform at their best.

The organisations that consistently outperform their competitors understand that sustainable success depends not only on what their managers know, but on how effectively they lead people.

Investing in leadership capability is therefore not simply a people initiative, it is a business strategy.

Comments


bottom of page